December 11, 2007

Holidailies Charity Project: the feedback

Last week, Chip and I asked Holidailies participants to give us their feedback on what they'd like (or not like) to see in a potential Holidailies Charity Project. A number of people wrote some great entries, which I thought I'd share with you. Nearly all the organizations you all recommended were interesting and meaningful to me in some way -- I'd love to be able to pull together the cash to donate to all of them, myself.

First of all, you've probably read Chip's entry, which was the original petition for feedback ... but you might have missed the comments. Chip mentioned literacy-related organizations, and we received a number of related suggestions.

Donors Choose was one charity suggested by multiple online writers -- teachers who need materials for disadvantaged students ask for funding for specific projects, and you pick the project where your money will go. Megan from Elbowglitter explained more how the Donors Choose program works. Mel at Catchy Name Needed also likes the organization.

LB at Visible Woman introduced us to a group that promotes children's writing, Badgerdog Literary Publishing (right here in Austin, too).

Miriam Nadel at Areas of Unrest suggests two literacy-related groups: an organization in her area called The Book Thing, and the nationwide group The Libri Foundation.

Another literacy project called First Book was recommended by Erin over at well.notes.

Another book-related project: TigerWillow of I Am This Woman is supporting World Care's books and supplies program.

Heifer International was a popular suggestion from Holidailies members. Katie mentioned that it's a great organization for teaching your kids about charity. Reb at Chewbecca.com also likes the organization, and provides some related music for your entertainment.

Ruth at Mary and Bob's Journal suggested we pick Big Brothers Big Sisters, in an entry that talks about her own rewarding experiences as a Big Sister. She followed up the next day with another entry about her work with a local event called Angel Store.

Meloukhia at This Ain't Livin' offers a number of possible charities that help various groups of people.

Elizabeth at Another Random Memory not only agreed with the Donors Choose idea, she also suggested some groups that send care packages and gear to U.S. soldiers.

Ladyloo reminds us about the good things that the Salvation Army does.

Tasukitty recommends any animal shelter-related charitable groups, particular pit bull rescues. Oldy at Half Old Girl pleads for helping a pet shelter and adoption program (I think she'd like to see us all adopt cats).

Stacey at Ruined by Books tells us about the two groups for which she volunteers: Planned Parenthood and a needle exchange program.

Over at Music and Cats, Kimberley talks about her lunch at a restaurant run by FareStart, which provides homeless people with commercial culinary training.

Although Peasantwench at Musings of a Wench has already made her charity donations for the year, she wanted to tell us about Agape Hospice.

Not everyone wrote in support of the Holidailies Charity Project -- we didn't expect 100 percent support, of course. We were hoping for more constructive and less hurtful criticism than this, but we appreciate all feedback. We've tried to stress that the project is optional, and if it's something that doesn't interest you, feel free to ignore any and all posts about it.

If I missed any entries or comments related to suggestions for the Holidailies Charity Project, please let me know in the comments of this entry. Chip and I are reviewing all your suggestions and should have a proposal to share in a few days.

Posted at December 11, 2007 09:25 PM
Comments

One thing FFP has taught me about charities one supports is that you can maximize your contribution by talking to potential donors and explaining the project over and over and why you support it. Sometimes you just raise awareness. (You might just be talking to someone who could recommend a child to the program or get it in a school.) Sometimes you get cash. So, we appreciate getting to highlight Badgerdog, a group that we think is doing great things, in this forum.

I also like being part of something bigger than one's own potential contribution. I'm still feeling personally self-satisfied over the communication device Rob Rummel-Hudson raised money for (for his daughter) from his blog readers. Even though my contributions were small. They were made bigger by many other little contributions.

Posted by: Linda Ball at December 12, 2007 08:17 AM

Jette & Chip -
In case I haven't said it in so many words - thanks for making this a part of Holidailies. I've learned about some important organizations I may not have otherwise encountered. It's great to see where fellow writers' passions live.
Thanks for all you do,
Ruth

Posted by: Ruth at December 12, 2007 09:57 AM

p.s. - Thanks for mentioning my post regarding "Angel Store". I hope not to confuse anyone, though. My nomination is for Big Brothers Big Sisters. Angel Store is actually over for '07 - and was mentioned only to illustrate some lessons I've learned about giving.

:) Thanks.

Posted by: Ruth at December 12, 2007 10:07 AM

I also want to thank you for making this part of Holidailies. Even if a charity isn't chosen, it is nice to highlight all of these organizations and maybe someone will still contribute, either now or at another time of the year.

I think there are a lot of great charities out there. I know there has been a call for contributions to small, local charities, and I just wanted to say that in this instance, I tried to find something that was a little more wide-spread, something that everyone, or at least everyone in the United States, could feel some sort of a tie to. That said, maybe an international charity is the way to go, try to include everyone.

Either way, thank you. It is appreciated.

Posted by: Megan at December 13, 2007 07:21 AM

Me again!

http://roolily.wordpress.com/2007/12/15/another-psa/

Posted by: Ruth at December 15, 2007 10:55 PM

While I think giving to charity is a good thing, I have to admit that your singling out of a dissenting voice in your post above was a bit over the line. The writer was extremely polite, with valid points that were written in a respectful, stand-offish, but honest way.

Calling it "hurtful criticism" is unfair, and the way you link to her entry above smacks of spite.

Like her and a couple others who have read her journal, I'm quitting holidailies. I've enjoyed following the project for four years. Won't be continuing if this is the way you treat the people who help write for your project.

Posted by: at December 16, 2007 09:49 AM